Dr Hazem Lashin, Consultant in Critical Care Medicine, Barts Health NHS Trust, shares his top tips for those compiling a medical case report.
What is a medical case report?
A medical case report is a scientific manuscript describing a single case or a small group of cases with a common theme.
Why are medical case reports important?
Medical case reports are essential for several reasons:
- Knowledge sharing: They provide detailed accounts of individual patient cases, contributing to the broader medical knowledge base. This can help other healthcare professionals learn from unique or rare cases.
- Clinical insights: Case reports can highlight unusual disease presentations, novel treatment responses, or unexpected side effects, which can inform clinical practice and guide future research.
- Hypothesis generation: They can serve as a starting point for generating hypotheses for further research. Observations made in case reports can lead to larger studies or clinical trials.
- Education: Case reports are valuable educational tools for medical students and professionals. They illustrate real-life applications of medical knowledge and the complexities of patient care.
- Documentation of rare conditions: They are essential for documenting rare diseases or conditions that may not be well understood, helping to build a body of evidence over time.
- Ethical considerations: Case reports can raise awareness about ethical issues in medicine, such as informed consent and patient confidentiality, prompting discussions about best practices.
- Interdisciplinary learning: They often involve collaboration across different specialties, fostering a multidisciplinary approach to patient care and enhancing communication among healthcare providers.
Overall, medical case reports are crucial in advancing medical science, improving patient care, and fostering a culture of continuous learning in the healthcare community.
What makes a good case report?
A good medical case report typically includes several key elements that enhance its quality and usefulness. Here are some essential aspects to consider:
- Clear objective: The report should have a clear purpose, such as presenting a unique case, highlighting a rare condition, or discussing an unusual treatment response.
- Comprehensive patient history: A detailed patient history, including demographics, medical history, presenting symptoms, and relevant social and family history, is essential for context.
- Thorough clinical examination: The clinical findings should be described, including physical examination results and any diagnostic tests performed.
- Diagnostic process: The report should outline the diagnostic process, including differential diagnoses and the rationale for the final diagnosis.
- Treatment and management: It is crucial to provide a detailed account of the treatment plan, including medications, procedures, and any follow-up care. The plan should also discuss the patient's response to treatment.
- Discussion of findings: The report should include a Discussion section that contextualises the case in the existing literature. This may involve comparing the case to similar cases, discussing implications for practice, and highlighting novel findings.
- Conclusion: A concise conclusion summarising the key takeaways from the case and its relevance to clinical practice or future research is essential.
- Ethical considerations: Ensure patient confidentiality is maintained and obtain informed consent for publication if necessary.
- Clarity and structure: The report should be well-organized, clearly written, and free of jargon, making it accessible to a broad audience, including those outside the specific field of study.
- Visual aids: Including relevant images, charts, or tables can enhance understanding and provide visual context to the case.
By incorporating these elements, a medical case report can communicate important clinical insights and contribute to the medical literature.
How to write a case report
Writing a case report involves several structured steps to ensure clarity, comprehensiveness, and adherence to scientific standards. Here’s a guide to help you through the process:
- Choose a unique case: Select a case that is interesting, rare, or has unique features that contribute to medical knowledge.
- Obtain consent: Ensure you have the patient’s (or their guardian's) informed consent to publish their case, respecting confidentiality and ethical guidelines
- Structure your report: A typical case report includes the following sections:
- Title: Create a concise and informative title that reflects the essence of the case.
- Abstract: Write a summary (150-250 words) that includes the background, case presentation, and key findings or conclusions.
- Introduction: Provide background information on the condition or issue being discussed. Explain the significance of the case and its relevance to existing literature.
- Case presentation: Detail the patient’s demographics (age, sex, etc.), medical history, presenting symptoms, clinical findings, diagnostic tests, and treatment. Be thorough but concise.
- Discussion: Examine the case within the framework of existing literature. Compare and contrast it with other cases, discussing practical implications and any new insights. Emphasise key learning points and identify potential future research avenues. This section serves as the core of the case report.
- Conclusion: Summarise the key takeaways from the case and its importance in clinical practice.
- References: Cite relevant literature and studies that support your discussion and provide context for your case.
- Acknowledgments (if applicable): Acknowledge any contributions from colleagues or institutions.
- Write clearly and concisely: Use clear and straightforward language. Avoid jargon and ensure that the report is accessible to a broad audience.
- Use visual aids: Include relevant images, charts, or tables to enhance understanding. Ensure that any images comply with ethical standards and patient confidentiality.
- Follow journal guidelines: If you plan to submit the case report to a medical journal, review and adhere to their specific submission guidelines regarding formatting, length, and style.
- Review and edit: Proofread your report for clarity, grammar, and accuracy. Consider seeking feedback from colleagues or mentors before submission.
- Submit for publication: Select a suitable journal focusing on case reports or your specific practice area and submit your manuscript following their guidelines. Also, consider whether they impose an article processing charge (APC) for case reports.
Following these steps, you can create a well-structured and informative case report contributing to the medical community's understanding of unique clinical scenarios.
Where to publish a medical case report
Medical case reports on echocardiography can be published in various journals focusing on cardiology, echocardiography, intensive care medicine, or general medical case reports.
Tips for choosing a journal
- Scope and focus: Ensure the journal's scope aligns with your case report topic.
- Impact factor: Consider the journal's impact factor and reputation in the field.
- Open access vs. subscription: Decide if you want your report to be open access, which may require a publication fee.
- Submission guidelines: Review the journal's submission guidelines for formatting and requirements.
Options to consider
Interested in submitting a case study for BSEcho 2025?
Find out more
Looking for tips on presenting a case study?
Check out our blog